Amazon Echo Show 5 vs Echo Show 8 – Which is best for Black Friday?

With the start of Black Friday, two of the standout deals are the recently launched Amazon Echo Show 5 and the Echo Show 8.

At full RRP the price difference is big enough to differentiate them, with the Echo Show 5 costing £79.99 and the Show 8 being £40 more at £119.99.

However, with Black Friday, things have changed, now there is just £10 difference with the Show 5 being £49.99 and the Show 8 being £59.99, both are an amazing buy, but should you fork out the extra for the larger model?

The TLDR would be yes. It is has a bigger screen and better screens easily justifying the cost.

Echo Show 8 (1st Gen, 2019 release) – Smart Display with...
  • Alexa can show you more: with an 8" HD screen and...
  • Connect with video calling and messaging: call...
  • Be entertained: ask Alexa to show you TV...
  • Control your smart home: voice control compatible...

As the name suggests the Echo Show 5 uses a 5-inch screen, 5.5-inch to be exact and this runs at a meagre 960 x 480 pixels.

The Show 8, unsurprisingly, has an 8-inch screen but this has a much larger resolution of 1280 x 800.

That’s probably worth the extra tenner already, but with speakers, size really does matter. The Echo Show 8 weighs more than double the Show 5 at 1037 g in a body measuring 200.4 x 135.9 x 99.1 mm this allows it to fit 2 x 2.0-inch speaker @ 10W per channel.

The Echo 5 which weighs just 410g and measures 148 x 86 x 73 mm has just a single 1.7-inch @ 4W. The quality of audio between the two devices will be night and day. To put it into context, the speaker in the Echo 5 is only slightly larger than the 1.6-inch inside the Echo Dot. While the latest dot is amazing for notifications and voice control, would you really want to watch a video or listen to music on it?

The dual 2-inch speakers of the Show 8 are not that much smaller than the dual 2.2-inch of the original show, and they run at the same 10W per channel.

Beyond these two very significant differences, both of the devices share mostly the same properties. In my opinion, the only reason to go for the smaller model is if you specifically need something a bit smaller due to space requirements. For example, I ordered the Show 8, but I want it to sit below my monitor, but I think it might be a little large.

Both the Show 5 and 8 use a 1MP front-facing camera for video calls, this is quite a bit lower than the 10-inch Show which has 5MP. The biggest show also has Dolby processing and a built-in Zigbee smart home hub, while these make that device the best option, the current price of  £159.99 mean it is not worth considering at all, unless a big discount happens later in the week.

Echo Show (2nd Gen) – Stay in touch with the help of Alexa...
  • New speakers with improved sound, a new 10” HD...
  • Call almost anyone hands-free including UK mobile...
  • Ask Alexa to see lyrics and album art with Amazon...
  • Your new kitchen companion—watch recipes, set...

Last update on 2021-07-27 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.